How does gratitude work?

I wrote the previous two posts as background explanation for some thoughts I had about gratitude.

Today I’ve been reading about shinto, and kami veneration, and the idea of expressing gratefulness to all the little parts of the world around you. I can get on board with this! I basically do this already, in my head, just walking around. Although when I do it, it has a much more analytical, post-industrial revolution flavor. I’m thinking about the complex interdependencies of the supply chain, and the electrical grid, and how extremely convenient it is that visible light just bounces all around and then ends up in our eyes, showing us detailed information about what’s distant.

I do it a lot, but I don’t do it in a ritualized way. But maybe I should? What exactly is gratitude, anyway? Like, literally what happens in your mind when you decide to enact the gratefulness feeling?

One obvious thing that can happen is that it can make you realize that some things were benefiting you in a way that you didn’t realize before. By “realize” I mean something more like “learn” or “come to understand”. Gratitude can change your beliefs about the systems you live in, and now your updated beliefs contain a part that tracks the positive effects you weren’t tracking before.

But I don’t think that’s the core of it. When I feel gratitude for something — let’s call it the “helpful thing” — I almost always knew beforehand that that thing was good for me.

But I’m still doing something, when I decide to enact the gratefulness feeling toward the helpful thing. Literally what am I doing?? (Analogously; literally how does the clock work??)

I do believe that minds are ultimately physical objects that are running a process, much like how a clock is running the process of tracking time, or how a computer runs the process of computation. So secretly, when I think about how minds work, I’m imagining a bunch of little bits of software interacting inside the squishy brain. This helps me to do more than shrug and think “consciousness, yeah who knows man” and move on. But I don’t necessarily expect you, the reader, to buy the computational theory of the mind in order to think more about how gratitude works.

I think another part of the answer is that gratitude involves bringing the helpful thing into your attention. I think attention is some special part of [the software of] your mind, and that bringing a concept into your attention is a genuine action you’re taking. But there’s also ways to bring the helpful thing into your attention where you don’t feel gratitude. For example you could be occupied with resentfulness at your dependency on the thing, or feel like it’s pointless to feel good about it because some other fact makes it moot.

So what is it that happens when you bring into your attention a helpful thing that you already know & understand, and then feel gratefulness about it?

Well, to be clear I’m not expecting to reveal the reasons why we have subjective experiences at all. I don’t know why blue looks blue. But I claim that humanity did basically figure out why primary colors feel primary, and others feel like a mixture of the primary colors, and not just a linear spectrum like sound, which is because we have three types of light receptors in our eyes that specialize in different regions of the frequency spectrum, and that the immediately downstream retina neurons do stuff like detecting patterns of contrast in these receptors, in a way that treats these receptors as three essentially symmetric basis vectors.

My proposal is that gratefulness is what it feels like to bring into your attention the helpful thing, and that it didn’t have to be that way. That there exists a counterfactual intervention to the system’s parameters such that the good thing didn’t happen. When I bring into my mind how a clock works, and then imagine picking up the weight, I can feel that the weight is necessary for the time-telling. And when I bring into my mind how the food supply chain works, and then imagine a trucker strike, I can feel that the truck drivers are necessary for my full pantry. And since I like having a full pantry, I feel positively toward the truck drivers.

Leave a Reply