Why do humans do what they do?

Carrying on from the previous post, one domain in which I try to understand what’s going on is people. How do humans work on the inside? What kind of mechanisms do they have running in there?

Human behavior is a domain where, after you’ve learned a predictive model, it’s very easy to come up with an explanatory mechanism that isn’t the right one. Is John quiet because he doesn’t think he’s cool enough to have earned people’s attention, or because he thinks everyone else is an idiot and not worth talking to?

It can also be very tempting to throw up your hands and say “we could never know how they work on the inside”. There was an entire period of the science called Behaviorism where this was the accepted paradigm. Some went as far as saying that it was meaningless to even claim that there was something going on on the inside.

It is indeed much harder to tinker with human minds than clocks, in order to perform the intervention you want to observe. But that doesn’t mean there is no fact of the matter about what is going on on the inside, and it doesn’t mean that all predictively explanatory theories are equally valid.

I find that I’m very interested in knowing what kinds of things humans have been up to. This interest leads me to read about things like culture, history, or art. There are also lots of human activities I seem not to be interested in understanding (how tax law works, the FIFA World Cup, Brits’ obsession with the Queen) and the interest is generally impersonal. But it’s quite persistent, and seems to be a terminal value. I would like to understand this drive of mine better, but that’s something to investigate another time.

One such domain of human activity that I spend at least a moderate amount of time learning about and trying to understand is religion. I’m not trying to figure out which of the religions are true or “the right one for me”. I am a committed atheist, and feel very comfortable with my worldview and beliefs around ethics, the existence of the universe, the origin of life, et cetera. I also have come to terms with the implication that the vast majority of humans seem to believe or participate in major systems that are obviously wrong and make no sense.

I’ve come to terms with it, but I don’t really understand it. If you tweaked some parameters of the system, I wouldn’t be able to predict what would happen. And I’m curious. What are the humans up to? Why do they do these things?

Sometimes I find components of these cultural systems that resonate with me, like celebrating the life-giving power of the sun, or writing meaningful passages over and over, or surrounding yourself with beautiful geometric mosaics. And I feel something like, oh, should I join in? That sounds nice, would people mind if I did that too? But if I did, would I even be doing the same thing they’re doing? What, exactly, are they doing when they do that ritual? What is happening in their mind? And is that what would be happening in my mind, if I did it too?

Leave a Reply